Home > Biology > Growing Plants in Different Soils

Growing Plants in Different Soils

By: Suzanne Elvidge BSc (hons), MSc - Updated: 19 Feb 2019 |
Plants Water Air Food Nutrients Growing

Like animals and humans, plants need water, air and food to grow. They get all of these from their growing medium – the compost or soil that they grow in. This experiment looks at the effect that different growing mediums – sand, soil, compost, and bark – have on the plants, as well as what happens when plants get too much water.

Planting The Beans

Take five plastic cups and make drainage holes in four of them. Starting with the four with drainage holes, fill one with sand, one with soil from the garden, one with shredded bark and one with potting compost from the garden centre and label each one. Fill the cup without drainage holes with potting compost and label it ‘waterlogged’. Plant two or three bean seeds in each one. Water the pots gently, put them on a warm, bright windowsill and wait a week or two for the beans to germinate.

When the pot with potting compost and drainage holes starts to dry out, water them all with the same amount of water, and make sure that they all get the same amount of light.

Once the beans have started to sprout, give them sticks to climb up and measure them every day for a couple of weeks. See which plants grow the most quickly, and check which plants look the healthiest – are the leaves all the same colour?

What Has Happened?

The beans planted in the potting compost in the cup with drainage holes are likely to be the tallest and look the healthiest, with large dark green leaves, because potting compost drains well, so that the plants don’t become waterlogged, but holds enough moisture to keep the plants healthy. It also has all the nutrients that the plants need.

The other plants may not do as well. Garden soil tends to get waterlogged and compacts in the pot, so the roots may have too much water, which can make them rot, and may also not have enough air. Some soils don’t have enough nutrients for the plants, so they might start well, but begin to look a bit sickly after a while.

Sand drains very quickly, so the bean plants may not get enough water. It also doesn’t contain many nutrients. Because of this, bean plants grown in sand can be short and stunted, and might be pale. Shredded bark also drains quickly and is low in nutrients, so these plants may not do as well.

The waterlogged plants will struggle to grow – they have plenty of water and nutrients, but the roots need oxygen as well, and little will get to their roots. If they germinate at all, they are likely to rot and die after a while.

What Does This Mean?

The roots of plants take nutrients and water from the soil for the plant. The roots also need oxygen from the air in order to remain healthy. While different plants do need different growing conditions, it’s generally important to make sure that they have all of these in order to grow well and produce fruit, vegetables, flowers, seeds and grains.

You might also like...
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice..
this has been very helpful for my science experiment thank you
falcon - 19-Feb-19 @ 4:02 PM
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice...
(never shown)
(never shown)
(never shown)
(never shown)
Enter word:
Latest Comments
  • simran panaich
    Re: Soap and Detergent Chemistry
    thnx!! It helped me a lot !!! THank YOu so much
    6 June 2019
  • Mar2
    Re: Why Oil and Water Don't Mix
    I am doing this as a demo for homogeneous mixture examples. It really helps, it is interesting, and thank you so much for it!!!
    5 June 2019
    Re: Why Oil and Water Don't Mix
    Why does the food coloring mix with the water i did not quite get iy
    31 May 2019
    Re: Looking at Soil Profiles
    This thing is stupid. I am a doctor and I know better then you do! I will do something about this website if you don’t change the…
    25 May 2019
  • Alice Picello
    Re: Looking at Soil Profiles
    25 May 2019
  • Rea
    Re: Making an Emulsion
    I have always wondered about the Earth. My teacher gave us this website to read about why water and oil don't mix. I started looking around on…
    16 May 2019
  • Candytashy
    Re: Looking at Soil Profiles
    Thanks so much for this post .it really helped me .made my homework much easier and l have learnt a lot from this post
    25 March 2019
  • Rajput
    Re: Pulling and Pushing: Magnetic Attraction
    Kya kisi chemical ko copper me mix karne se iron or steel ko push kiya ja sakte hai. Yadi ho to formula batye.
    25 March 2019
    Re: Soap and Detergent Chemistry
    Thanks you so much because you help different students especially science who went be a perfect a part of chemistry
    22 March 2019
    Re: Soap and Detergent Chemistry
    Thanks you so much because you help d/f students especially science who went be a perfect a part of chemistry like me.
    22 March 2019